I accidentally posted this to !android@lemdro.id before I noticed the sidebar said to ask buying suggestion questions here:
I’m looking to replace my failing phone. I don’t need fancy hardware in terms of camera, high storage, any crazy screen technology or the like. I don’t need a large sized phone, in fact I’d prefer something on the smaller side. I need it to be either bloatware/spyware-free on arrival, or easily de-bloated (permanently). I am thinking that instead of running stock Android I’d probably try either LineageOS or /e/OS anyway, so that might solve the bloatware issue.
My most important factors to consider are:
- Price
- Battery life
- Headphone jack
- De-bloated or de-bloat-able
I haven’t been in the phone market for years and have not payed much attention to phone developments, so I’m kind of at a loss of where to start. What I’ve done so far is looked at the LineageOS supported devices, and it seems some of the lower-end Motorola phones might be the best fit for me. I looked at some of the higher-end phones that aren’t the newest generation as well, but there it seems like I may run the risk of not getting (security) updates for much longer, versus buying a newer lower-end phone.
Also: can carriers force push install apps if you’re running something other than stock Android? For example, if I use LineageOS can I prevent a carrier from pushing an app installation (even by SIM)?
Google services are totally optional and it downloads them only if you choose to install them. I actually have a separate user profile from the main one with it installed just for the odd app that actually has it as a hard requirement. Secondary profiles are also easy to just wipe when you don’t need them any more and you can checkbox install any app already on your main profile to them.
I haven’t heard of banking apps entirely not working when I was researching this phone choice. Basically if it doesn’t work right after installing it, you long press the icon, hit app info, scroll down and enable exploit protection compatibility. Mine needed this but has had no issues other than that.
You also don’t get root but that’s a security hole anyways. The one thing I wish you could do is copy libjni_latinimegoogle.so from the Google keyboard to the system lib/lib64 folders to get swipe typing on the stock keyboard which has worked for me on my previous phones. I’m currently using Gboard with all the permissions disabled in app settings and hopefully that’s good enough.
Graphene also has the built in OS updating you would expect of any stock rom which is nice since I had been manually updating custom roms for years now.