Debating on these two laptops… thoughts/opinions??

  • robertpetry@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    “No brainer” - Why?

    • Much better processor - Use case says there would be no difference in real life performance at all
    • Ability for 2 external displays - Most non-professionals do not use 2 external monitors. If they will, then yes, this is a good reason
    • Nearly the same weight - but not nearly the same size. Air 15 has over an inch larger screen. The 14 is closer in size to the Air 13.6. In person it is a big difference.
    • 120hz vs 60 - no going back - Really? on a laptop I didn’t see much difference side by side. Maybe for gaming or sports watching, but 60 is good enough for most uses.
    • HDMI port, good for travel in hotels if no airplay, or even at home in general - Agreed but a small adapter fits in any pocket on you case or sleeve. is that worth the extra weight and thickness?
    • Additional usb c port - Same as above
    • Keyboard is nice (on both) - That is personal preference. On the 14 the keystrokes needed felt longer and the heavier to me. I liked the lighter feeling on the Air.

    Depending upon use case and personal preferences, I think the decision could go either way. That is not a “no brainer.” IMHO.

    • mlouka@alien.topB
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      After no brainer I did follow that with how “I feel”. Personal preference trumps all if you know what you want, no problem with that. OP asked tor opinions.

      I’ve had a 13in, 15, 17, and now 16. Definitely agree that I’d prefer 15 over 14, but not to lose being able to connect 2 externals over without having to get additional accessories. 2 externals also need more power to run well.

      It’s also why I didn’t reply to your original comment because I’m not here trying to convince you that you made a wrong choice with getting the MacBook Air. You sound like you know what you want and what you wanted was the best choice for you, so who am I to advise you.

      But while we’re on the topic, it only weights .2 lbs more lol, and nominally thicker