Id say It is their single biggest problem and can be seen time and time again over the last few years. When things don’t go their way they completely lose their cohesion and give up. The biggest example of this is obviously the Liverpool 7 goal defeat.

How do you fix a team that won’t put it all on the line for the club? It’s a big issue that isn’t easily solved.

Yes but it’s not the only one

Does Man U have a problem in- Yes. Doesn’t matter what Yes there is are problems everywhere

Mentality is for sure one of the problems along with a pile of many others
just score first against us and we frantically run on the ground
comparison to real madrid they conceded a goal against Napoli and within a minute or so replied back with a banger of a goal

would you ever think after el classico if real loses can you imagine seeing vini patrying or rodrygo partying ofc no
but after the loss against city rashford was reportedly seen partying the same night

rashford is not a bad player but its all about the mentality and the willingness for the team and not just playing for the paycheck

United have many many many problems, mentality is just one of them.

They have a lack of quality in the starting XI and next to no depth, they have players on massive wages for absolutely no reason, and they like many other teams are struggling with injuries, another big problem they have is their best players can’t play the way the best teams in the league play, and likely how ETH wants to play

They do, but they’ve also pulled out last minute points several times this season which shows me there’s something there.

It’s the top 4 is a trophy mentality everyone bar City seem to have coming home to roost.

It’s probably a bit of everything. Mentality, questionable decisions in transfer windows, strained relationships with key players (from Ronaldo to Maguire and now Sancho), and a reluctance to make significant changes in tactics.

Sure, injuries didn’t help either, but I’m struggling to notice any on-field improvement since ETH took charge at United…

Nah we’re just trash all round, any team that loses to us should be embarrassed.

What Manchester United have is a horrible coach.
What Manchester United have are banal players who cost many millions and who protect each other by defending mediocrity.
What Manchester United has is unambitious fans who forgive this manager everything and blame the board.
As someone has already pointed out Manchester United has stopped in time.

I think it all comes from the management after all.

Remember Ronaldo’s interview with Piers Morgan, all of the stuff he said seems to be true and it is just sad that the team hasn’t made any progress at all during the last 10 years.

United fans have been saying this for years. Its not a revelation.

All of these intangibles like mentality, experience, composure start to come out when a big team performs consistently poorly, but I think the answer is a lot simpler. Transfer business from United, over the last 10 years, has been categorically horrendous. People bringing up mentality seem to imply that it’s the mentality that’s letting them down and that the players are losing because of their weak mentality - no, the team is just crap. It’s not a top 4 team. United have a weird propensity to sign glamorous players with strong resumes that drop off after 1-2 years, giving them high wages which restricts investment elsewhere. And after the 1-2 years is up, it’s rinse and repeat - no semblance of a plan, a project, or a cohesive pathway forward. Their team right now is only Europa League standard, which is why their performances have reflected that.

Feel like man utd only knows how to play the long pass no matter the situation. Win lose or draw it’s always long pass to the forwards which results in lost of possession and a lack of control over the game giving the opposition chances to score

I m Galatasaray fan but ı was surprised that Galatasaray beat Man United and Man United finished 4th in Group A.