• 20 Posts
  • 22 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 17th, 2023

help-circle



  • I’m experiencing similar things:

    • Posts made here not appearing on other federated instances
    • Posts made by other federated instances disappearing or never appearing in communities here

    I’ve checked with alt accounts created on lemm.ee and sh.itjust.works which are subscribed to the same communities.

    @ruud@lemmy.world Is there a federation issue?

    Edit: I think this is a problem with all communities on lemmy.ml. I’m new to the fediverse concept, but the issue seems to specifically be with them.


  • Lemmy.world has been acting strangely since yesterday’s upgrade, and has also been getting hugged by Reddit refugees.

    I think it’s having issues right now seeing posts elsewhere in the fediverse, and sharing posts made on lemmy.world with other servers.

    Using an alternate account on lemm.ee I can see a lot of lemmy.ml posts in here that aren’t visible on lemmy.world, and none of those instances seem to be defederated from each other.

    I expect it’s just growing pains and will be resolved soon.

    tl;dr You might want to make an alt.























  • Now imagine if your PlayStation can cross-play with a Nintendo Switch, and the XBox can cross-play with a PC. However, PC and Switch do not cross-play. That’s kind of how the Federation works. Different ‘hubs’ can pick and chose which other ‘hubs’ they talk to.

    This is one of the best explanations I’ve seen. Thank you.

    Slightly off-topic, but your example actually helps lessen my concern with what I understood about “defederating.”

    I almost “noped” on using Lemmy because I saw defederating as removing the choice from me as an individual. Instance admins can, at any time, remove my option to engage with users in another instance. Welcome to the echo chamber.

    But your example helps me see defederation in a slightly different light. I still get why it’s called “the nuclear option,” but it’s maybe more like “We don’t talk to Nazis, even if they don’t bring up white supremacy while discussing beekeeping.”

    So while I still don’t think the decision to defederate by Beehaw makes sense, I do have less concern about defederating as a concept. (Although I still want the ability to transfer my posts and comments to a different instance, should my instance admin make a decision I disagree with.)

    Thanks again!


  • This is helpful, thanks.

    It doesn’t cost you anything to sign up for, so give it a try.

    The main cost is time, to understand the platform and to find community. I created a Kbin account, but I don’t see myself having the time to be divided between Kbin and Lemmy so I’m hoping not to have to maintain both.

    Kbin federates with Lemmy - so users can engage in each other’s posts.

    This gives me hope. So is it basically just a different UI? This is where my understanding of the fediverse breaks down.


  • Can you elaborate?

    I read that Kbin defederated with Lemmy because it couldn’t initially handle the influx of new users migrating from Reddit, but that it has federated again.

    So is it a Lemmy instance, like Beehaw?

    I know that Kbin doesn’t use communities (“/c/”) but uses magazines (“/m/”) so I thought it was different.

    I also read that there was some new way to post to Lemmy from Mastadon, but I thought those were different, like Reddit and Twitter. But they both rely on something called “ActivityPub”?

    So is Kbin similar to Lemmy (by being Reddit-like), but distinct like Mastadon (which is Twitter-like)?

    I didn’t have a Twitter account, but was a heavy Reddit user. I don’t have a Mastadon account, but I’m liking Lemmy. However I have some FOMO about Kbin because I don’t understand how it all works together.