Downvotes rewarded with hugs.

  • 23 Posts
  • 569 Comments
Joined 8 months ago
cake
Cake day: October 30th, 2023

help-circle





  • First, I’m fairly sure both the Beeb and the Mouse Corp are watching Doctor Who ratings on a much wider timescale than the armchair analysts, worrywarts and doomsayers out there.

    I don’t know how long Disney secured distribution rights for but with their penchant for hoarding IPs they might even be in for a long game of securing international rights for the entire series back catalogue when they expire with other parties. Star Wars, the MCU — they know from experience what kind of synergy a 60 year franchise can build when it’s collected in one place.

    Second, though, we’ll have to see if Disney’ll invest in the spinoffs right away. I’d love to see that “War between the land and the sea” thing materialise, whatever it is, and it sounds like Bad Wolf have been setting it up. As for the UNIT show, if that’s even separate from the other spinoff… at least the primary set is already built?







  • Different strokes, I guess. To me the discomfort of the unexplained in 73 yards is the source of (mild, child friendly) horror that drives the episode, and makes the story stick with you. 🤷

    Rogue was a terrific throwback to fun, slightly bizarre period romps, but apart from introducing a new love interest for the Doctor I think it sits nicely in a third place? Now, if it had had full body holograms of all past Doctors gyrating to “Can’t get you out of my head” along with 15 I’d rank it higher…


  • I’m curious why The church on Ruby Road wasn’t included in the poll as it so clearly was a part of this season’s storyline — and I wonder where it would have landed in the ranking.

    The result of the poll is fairly similar to my own personal ratings. OTOH I’d swap 2 and 4, as well as 7 and 8 — mind you, that’s as subjective as it is going to fluctuate with rewatches.

    Edited to add:

    You know what, here is my ranking of the moment. I added in the christmas special and rewatched a couple of episodes I was uncertain about.

    1. 73 yards
    2. Dot and bubble
    3. Rogue
    4. Boom
    5. The church on Ruby Road
    6. The devil’s chord
    7. Space babies
    8. The legend of Ruby Sunday
    9. Empire of death

    I guess it reflects my disappointment that one quarter of the season was pissed away on a story about a Bad Dog being taken for walkies during Avengers: Endgame. The more standalone episodes worked much better for me than the “arc” this year.









  • I think the scene in Empire of death where the Doctor and Ruby debate her reconnecting with her mum is a template for his inner dilemma re Susan.

    He says straight out to Ruby that her birth mother never reached out for “7000 days” so maybe she’s not interested? That to me shows his own apprehension of not getting back in touch with Susan all those millennia (more than 7000 years in his timeline), but Ruby’s instinctive decision to go meet Louise could show him that there is still time for him, too.

    I mean, that’s what I hope! And I completely agree, any reunion with Susan that doesn’t include Carole Ann Ford would just not ring true.