I was gonna comment StarCraft Ghost since I believed no one even remembered it. Imagine my surprise reading it in so many comments! I hope Blizzard reads this thread.

But I’m gonna have to say Assassin’s Creed III. I felt so heartbroken when the series abruptly ended… I really wanted to know what happened to Desmond after Brotherhood!

I was just about to comment that! I know it wouldn’t be up for today’s standards, but man did it sound great back then.