The same opensource app, downloadable on both stores but paid on playstore and free on fdroid. Is it legal and is it ethical? Why?

  • theshatterstone54
    26·
    2 months ago

    True, but I think typically the Playstore version isn’t always from the official maintainers and I’d consider it less trustworthy, even if free (unless the devs link to the playstore page on github/gitlab/codeberg/whatever).

    • ReversalHatchery@beehaw.orgEnglish
      5·
      2 months ago

      the play store version isn’t as trustworthy even if the original devs published it there, since google forced all developers a few years ago to hand over their signing keys. the signature is how you know the app wasn’t modified by anyone, and that actually the developer released the apk

        • ReversalHatchery@beehaw.orgEnglish
          1·
          2 months ago

          yeah. the reason is that they can get away with that.

          this change was bundled with another one that was kind of good to have: building apps to an .aab file and making split apk’s out of it.
          but in this scheme the dev builds the .aab, and google makes the split apk’s, and google needs your signing key to make the signed split APKs. the reason they need your formerly used signature’s keys is because if they would have started signing apps with a new one, users who had your app already installed would have had to first uninstall the app and lose their data, because android has a security feature that does not allow an update that has a different signature.

          of course, while at first it was an option, the play store has soon made it a requirement that you upload your apps as .aab files.
          developers basically didn’t have a choice, other than not releasing any more updates to the play store and letting google delete “outdated” apps when they want, like they’ll have a sweep soon.

          • theshatterstone54
            2·
            2 months ago

            Fuck Google, man. Split apks make it super difficult to find, extract and install modded apps.

          • theshatterstone54
            1·
            2 months ago

            I so hope they get broken down, AND have to pay some outrageous fines before that, AND have to comply to some insane rules that restrict them hard. And then make the rules apply to all of Big Tech: Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, Meta, make them all suffer as they should, after the damage they’ve caused.