Now that we’re officially in October, horror fans are scouring all of their services to try to find the best movies that will help prepare themselves for Halloween. Between the number of horror services out there and the vastness of these libraries, many of which are underwhelming titles, it can be a bit tricky to find something a subscriber might not actually be familiar with that’s worth investing time in. While a variety of services offer up a long list of classic films that are well worth revisiting, some viewers who might be newer to the genre have the opportunity to check out under-seen experiences that are bound to become classics.

It might be hard to find horror titles the horror fanatics haven’t already seen, but for anyone who might skip over some lesser-known titles to just look for recognizable experiences, we’ve got you covered. Whether we’re looking at foreign horror, movies that never earned major promotional campaigns, or earlier efforts from filmmakers who have been given exciting opportunities in recent years, we know just what you should check out this October to celebrate some off-the-radar titles that are just as effective as major releases…

• The Autopsy of Jane Doe - Netflix
• Creep and Creep 2 - Netflix
• Drag Me to Hell - Prime Video
• The Eyes of My Mother - Hulu
• Hagazussa: A Heathen’s Curse - Prime Video
• The House of the Devil - Prime Video
• I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House - Netflix
• I Saw the TV Glow - Max
• Immaculate - Hulu
• The Invitation - Prime Video
• The Killing of a Sacred Deer - Max
• Mandy - Hulu
• Monster Inside: America’s Most Extreme Haunted House - Hulu
• Paranormal Activity 3 - Max
• Ready or Not - Hulu
• Saint Maud - Prime Video
• Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark - Netflix
• Trick 'r Treat - Max