Same. And I don’t realize I’m doing it. It feels like they’re completely there, but if I suddenly had to nail down the details, I would realize it’s just a vague idea.

Make sure it’s not upside down. (Pin should be facing out.) I assume you tried it a few times. Sometimes they don’t click right away. Does your old band still click in? You might just be out of luck.

Because the face still lights up when you move

That’s weird. I’m pretty sure my Watch 3 had it.