I prefer an apartment that I have to clean myself
The shitty thing is that you have to clean it yourself and then they charge a “cleaning fee”.
In Australia, I’ve also seen a relative rise of what are basically just hotels. The Airbnbs I’ve used overseas (admittedly not recently) have felt just like what you described. In Australia they’ve felt more like an apartment or townhouse bought by someone with the explicit intent to rent out as an Airbnb, with a whole bunch in the same building or complex owned for that purpose—or at least the vibe that that’s the case. A couple in Brisbane that my parents have used a few times when visiting is even in the same building as a hotel. Some rooms are hotel, others are privately-owned apartments, many of which are seemingly Airbnbs. (One of said hotels made the news recently for a really awful cockroach infestation, which is neat…) You feel just as disconnected from the city as you would in a hotel. Perhaps even more so, since in a hotel there’s at least a semblance of a sense of connectedness to other hotel patrons, which you lose in these hotel-based Airbnbs.
Part of this comes about because of bad local government policies. Airbnb being used for housing would be much less of a problem if:
Restrictions on Airbnb are a good idea, in my mind, but they’re a bandaid solution. They don’t address the underlying issue, which is that there literally isn’t enough housing to satisfy demand for residents, and in some tourist areas there aren’t enough hotels at the price points customers are demanding.
The biggest long-term problem with Airbnb, which would still exist even if housing were abundant, is its unregulated nature. Its customers need to be assured that they can get reliable help if there is a major fault with the service, just like they could with any other business. Regulating them like hotels, with some easing of that regulation in some aspects (but not the key ways affecting customer experience) for Airbnbs that are used only for a few weeks per year while the long-term resident is away, is something that needs to happen regardless.