zephyreks [none/use name]

  • 2 Posts
  • 185 Comments
Joined 10 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 5th, 2023

help-circle



  • China’s economy grew 5.3% in the first quarter, beating expectations

    Real estate continues deleveraging, and yet 5.3% GDP growth YoY.

    Retail sales growth continues to be sluggish (3.1% vs. 4.6% predicted) and CPI is coming in cool (0.1% vs. 0.3% predicted). My theory for this is that China is actually seeing costs drop more quickly than CPI metrics can keep up. Traditional big-ticket household spending categories are housing, transportation, and education. Housing prices are obviously on the decline, but transportation costs are also decreasing due to the combination of cheaper EVs and an expanding HSR network. Education costs have been clamped down on after the crackdown on private tutoring, while average education outcomes have been raised by the crackdown on gaming. Meanwhile, traditional recurring costs like food and energy have been pushed downward by increasing trade with Russia as well as the rise of cheap solar.

    It may be time to revisit the notion of ever-increasing consumption value as being important for economic growth. In this case, you can get the same quality of life with substantially less money. Why spend more to pad the top line retail sales number?











  • A stock market that always goes up is just poor allocation of capital, right? Wealth must come from somewhere and flow somewhere. If a stock market continues to see growth, it inherently means wealth will flow towards those with the greatest stock value (the shareholders). By extension, wealth must be created by the workers, and this type of stock market serves only to transfer wealth from workers to shareholders.

    A stock market is supposed to be used to efficiently allocate capital between different options, so assessing the aggregate value of a market sounds like it doesn’t capture the actual point of the market, right? Assuming no economic growth and fixed interest in an entirely free market, you’d expect that stock market returns should be ~nil since it should efficiently allocate capital to where it’s needed: profit in one sector and loss in another sector should equalize.

    All this is to say: Japan’s Nikkei has been going up despite a recession, and China’s Hang Seng has been going down despite 5% growth. Yet, everyone points to the Chinese stock market as if it’s an indicator for China’s economy.