I’m not talking “you don’t need a knife” level here, I’m looking for, “you need a spoon to finish the last bits” level of falling apart.
What are your specific techniques and tricks for different cuts?
Also, if you know a great Tennessee style dry rub I really want to know about it please.
Braise the cut in a cast iron dutch oven.
Yep Braising is the way. It’s amazing for tougher cuts. I do a brisket ragu 160oC for 4-6 hrs, a parchment paper lid and uncovered for the last 2 hrs. A dutch oven isn’t necessary, I sometimes use a stewpot or a chef’s pan.
Low and slow is my advice too - but also IME there’s something magical that happens when you use creamy soups as a starter with your meats. I spent years trying to make something healthier than my mom’s roast beef recipe, which is basically cream of mushroom soup and onion soup mix plus a roast, but nothing I did could make it fall apart and stay moist like hers. I settled on using real onions in place of the onion soup mix which helps lower the salt content a bit but my family often asks me to just make it like my mom did.
Slow and low. As someone mentioned below, keeping the meat covered while cooking in a dutch oven or tall roasting dish is crucial for making sure that it doesn’t dry out. In a pinch the crappy aluminum roasting pans will work just fine, the key is that your roasting container should be taller than the meat do that you can cover it while it’s cooking. For beef and pork, around 200 Fahrenheit and for chicken thighs, around 275. Chicken breasts don’t have enough fat as it is white meat so I wouldn’t try them slow and low. Just cook until it falls apart to your liking, time depends on the size and cut but those temperatures will do you just fine.
For Pork Shoulder, I found Michael Rhulmans recipe to be pretty versitile:
To cook the pork, as noted in post: Ideally, sear it hard over coals in the Weber, covered for 20 to 30 minutes, then put it in a Dutch oven, covered, for 6 hours at 250 degrees (or 4 hours at 300˚F). I think smoke is critical, but if you want to make it super easy on yourself, put the raw shoulder in a Dutch oven and roast it covered at 225 overnight and that’ll do the trick as well. Stir in the sauce. Taste for seasoning—salt, sweetness, acidity,heat. Adjust as you wish
The key is low and slow. Under 300 and over 4 hours. The key is to keep the mead moist or it will be dry and no good. If you seal the meat inside a container the water genreally stays in place. Once you get a better idea about it all, exposing the meat to smoke or limited high temp that causes browning enhances the flavor.
My technique is to “shock” the meat (not sure of the right term here) and then turn the heat way down and go low and slow… So for example… If I have a 5 lb shoulder roast I’ll go 1/2 hour uncovered at 475F and then turn it down to 200-250 and go another 4 or so hours (still uncovered) or til it’s about 165 internal on a meat thermometer. The 1/2 hour at 475 forms the crust and seals in the juices.
Definitely tent the meat for a few hours while cooking.
Giggity.
I do a Sous vide at 160 for 18 hours or so. Meat falls apart and is incredibly easy to make. Just finish under the broiler and you’re good to go.
Probably pretty different than what you’re looking for, but it definitely falls apart for pork shoulders.
https://www.seriouseats.com/sous-vide-carnitas-crispy-mexican-style-pulled-pork-recipe
Marinade, then slow cook in pan with foil on low heat. I can almost taste the brisket just writing this.
No, that’s the tri tip I just finished for dinner. It was pretty good. But this is broil-high for 15 minutes on each side, then 5 hours at 100C/200F. I flip it halfway through the low and slow. That really helps, but I can’t seem to get it to fall apart completely. This is loose but not falling apart.
The simple answer is braising. Low and slow, it will work.
Fat and connecting tissue melts with heat, that’s what gelatin is.
Time and heat=fallapart dry meat. Balance heat and time to have it fall apart and not be dry, but you can’t perfectly have both. Sous vide, lowest possible foodsafe temp and long time works pretty good, but you still don’t want to go overboard.
Also, everybody likes the mallard reaction and browning and you don’t get that with low heat (like 129F).
If all you want is fall-apart meat, that’s easy, though, just render all the connective tissues into liquid.
Dutch oven in an oven, lid on, 250°F for 3-5 hours. Perfect for a 3 lb corned beef brisket, probably works on other things.
