I dont like tankies or tories any more than the next person, but breaking federation is just wrong.

I dont want to have to make a separate account just to get around that, mainly because this is actually already my account for getting around that!

Its quite easy to block a community at user level, if needed, and we are not the target of any spam, but now we users have lost the option of the ability to interact forever with a corner of the threadiverse, which i think is not cool.

If its just me thinking this way, fine, i’ll just maintain several accounts, but i would hope its not, because its feeling like instances are gettinh pretty triggerhappy with the block button https://github.com/maltfield/awesome-lemmy-instances/tree/main

  • tkc
    13·
    1 year ago

    I’m generally against defederation as much as possible, but would personally prefer that the proper NSFW stuff wasn’t on my feed.

    It can be a bit jarring to be scrolling through content and there’s suddenly an anus or something on my screen…

    I don’t think it’s too much for people to have a separate account for porn and such if they want to see that, and it helps protect the feddit.uk instance from legal issues.

    • obosob
      2·
      1 year ago

      It appears this instance straight-up has NSFW disabled, you can’t opt-in to seeing NSFW posts on your feed nor make posts marked as such. I might be wrong about what it being disabled means. So that issue may be moot and not require defederation.

      One the flip side I do wonder if a blanket disabling of “NSFW” is too much, there are plenty of things that one might reasonably wish to mark or be marked as NSFW that is not porn, gore, or other such content. This could have the effect of either stifling some of the communities on this instance or people posting things in the grey area without marking them NSFW, even if they would have if the button to do so we’re present and people scrolling may have preferred that they did.

      Food for thought.

    • ᴇᴍᴘᴇʀᴏʀ 帝A
      1·
      1 year ago

      I don’t think it’s too much for people to have a separate account for porn and such if they want to see that

      Indeed - a blanket “no defederation” policy wouldn’t work because, I assume (I’m definitely not looking), there’s already some pretty nasty places out there that you can’t or don’t want to be linked to. However, it’d take a special kind of maniac to be subscribed to extreme material with their main account and most people would want a second account for that kind of thing anyway.